Tuft and Needle vs Casper: Which Mattress Is the Right One for You?

tuft and needle vs casper

The easy access and affordability of purchasing a foam mattress are almost irresistible. Considering that traditional mattresses can run from an average of $1,200 to $3,000, more consumers are choosing foam. But which one is better when comparing Tuft and Needle vs Casper? Both are popular brands with buyers, and both have their advocates.

Even though foam mattresses are less expensive than the traditional type, you don’t want to waste your time or money if it doesn’t fit your sleep style. When spending as much as a third of your life sleeping, you want to make sure any mattress you choose lives up to its claims. And sleep comfort is such an individual and subjective subject. The mattress you love might be torture for someone else.

​Comparing Tuft and Needle Mattress vs Casper

​Although both companies offer a sleep trial, we’ll provide some data to help you determine which will most likely fit your budget and your back. Let’s take a look at some of each brand’s main features, like construction and firmness.

Reputation and history: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Launched in 2012, Tuft and Needle was one of the first direct-to-consumer foam mattress manufacturers on the market. Founders Daehee Park and TJ Marino previously served as software engineers. However, their mutual dissatisfaction with the typical mattress-purchasing process inspired them to open Tuft and Needle.

Casper, also known as Casper Sleep, followed two years later in 2014. Founder Philip Krim had experience in the industry, which helped the younger company build their brand and gain exposure.

While both companies are Better Business Bureau accredited with A+ ratings, consumers have registered more complaints about Casper compared to Tuft and Needle.

Construction: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

​Tuft and Needle offers two mattress types: the original model and the “Mint” model. Casper offers three types: the Wave, the Casper, and the Essential. Based on their similar construction, we decided to compare the original Tuft and Needle vs Casper original.

Tuft and Needle Mattress

Tuft and Needle mattress construction

For Tuft and Needle, the original mattress model comprises two layers of foam. The top layer, made of the company’s proprietary “Adaptive Foam,” provides a soft layer with enough give to “sink,” and includes graphite and gel for a cooler sleeping experience.

Tuft and Needle boasts that the minimal layers, along with a breathable Tactel cover, draw heat away from the body and provide better ventilation. Some industry reviewers, however, noted that the ticking was so thin that they could see the foam through it.

Beneath the comfort layer lies the firmer support layer that gives the mattress its shape and supports the sleeper. Together with both layers, the mattress measures 10 inches tall.

casper mattress

Casper Sleep mattress construction

With the Casper basic model, buyers get four layers of foam: a top open-cell layer that provides some bounce and provides coolness, a pressure relief layer of memory foam, a “zoned” layer that varies in firmness for different pressure points, and last, a firm support layer. The zoned layer provides softness and the ability to sink at the shoulders while providing more support for the trunk and hips to align the spine.

Memory foam relieves pressure on the shoulders and hips. However, many people find sleeping on memory foam makes for excess warmth. So, using a poly foam layer on top provides a compromise. The Casper mattress also measures 10 inches tall.

The mattress ticking was designed more for durability than breathability. But Casper boasts their zippable mattress cover will stand the test of time.

Mattress firmness: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Topper

Many industry reviewers rate the T&N and Casper mattress at a slightly more than average firmness rating of 6.5 out of 10. However, Consumer Reports rated both mattresses with a 5 firmness level.

Despite the number of layers used, both the Casper and the T&N mattresses provide a top, 3-inch comfort layer for softness before the sleeper sinks to the firmer foundation layers. This results in a similar firmness rating for both beds.

However, what comprises the layers may make a difference to some sleepers. The memory foam layer in the Casper mattress provides some molding around the body and gives a more supportive feel. The T&N mattress allows the sleeper to float above the foundation layer. A previous review of the T&N mattress noted that smaller and lighter users didn’t get an adequate amount of “sink” to the firmer layers.

So, the firmness of either mattress may depend solely on the size and weight of the sleeper. Heavier users may find they sink entirely through the Tuft and Needle mattress and end up resting on the foundation layer. This difference may mean larger sleepers find the T&N mattress firmer than the Casper model. Lighter and small sleepers may find them equally firm.

Weight distribution: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Along with firmness, different mattresses are better at supporting pressure points like shoulders and hips. Weight distribution describes how well the mattress spreads out your weight to lessen the pressure in the core region and through the shoulders.

Side sleepers may prefer the Casper model due to the zoned layer that provides more sink at the shoulders to alleviate pressure. The memory foam layer hugs and supports those pressure points, keeping them above the firm foundation.

Sides sleepers, especially larger ones, found that the top comfort layer collapsed under pressure points. This left them supported by the foundation layer, which many found too firm for comfort.

Motion transfer: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

When sharing a mattress, excess movement from others can disrupt your sleep. Motion transfer describes how well a mattress sends movement on one side to the other. The more motion transfer, however, the more likely one partner may be awakened by the other’s tossing and turning.

Motion transfer can also make a mattress less stable when rolling over or changing position. A shaky mattress can make moving around on it more work than it should be.

Several industry reviewers and consumer advocacy agencies rated the Tuft and Needle mattress adequate for motion transfer. However, many lauded the Casper Sleep mattress as superior for the lack of vibration and motion transfer. So, If you sleep with a partner who has restless leg syndrome, you may prefer the Casper model.

Durability: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Although industry reviews varied from one brand to the other, Consumer Reports rated both the Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses equally durable. Their testing program found only minor changes after eight years of simulated use for both mattresses.

Sizing: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Casper Sleep and Tuft and Needle mattresses come in all standard mattress sizes, including an extra-long twin for teens and single adults. They both also manufacture a California king size. Both mattresses are 10 inches thick, which means they’ll fit a standard pocket fitted mattress.

Pricing: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Along with minor differences in support, the most significant difference between the Tuft and Needle vs. Casper foam mattresses is the price.

Tuft and Needle provides their mattress at a significantly lower cost than Casper Sleep. The prices for each size shake out as follows at the time of writing: Tuft and Needle, $350 – $750 and Casper, $595 – $1,195. Prices listed on the websites may change and depend on size, from twin to California king.

Tuft and Needle Sizes

  • ​Twin
  • ​Twin XL
  • ​Full
  • check
    ​Queen
  • check
    ​King
  • check
    ​California King

Casper Sleep

  • ​Twin
  • ​Twin XL
  • ​Full
  • check
    ​Queen
  • check
    ​King
  • check
    ​California King

​This vast difference means that the Casper mattress can run as much as 70 or 80 percent higher than the Tuft and Needle brand.

Warranty: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Both Casper and Tuft and Needle offer similar 10-year warrantees, as well as 100-night trials before committing to the purchase.

Consumer Advocate Ratings: Tuft and Needle vs Casper

Consumer Reports rated both mattresses with favorable scores. While Tuft and Needle receive a CR rating of 74, Casper received an impressive 80 overall score. Detailed ratings included:

Tuft and Needle

  • ​Durability: Excellent
  • ​Stability: Very Good
  • ​Petite to Large Side Sleepers: Very Good
  • check
    ​Petite Back Sleepers: Very Good
  • check
    ​Average and Large Back Sleepers: Good

Casper Sleep

  • ​Durability: Excellent
  • ​Stability: Very Good
  • ​Side Sleepers: Very good
  • check
    ​Smaller Back Sleepers: Excellent
  • check
    ​Average to tall back sleepers: Very good

What Do Customers Have to Say?

​Along with industry reviews, feedback for both mattresses show high customer satisfaction ratings.

Consumer Reports

Consumer Reports customer feedback for the Tuft and Needle mattress resulted in an average of 4.2 stars out of 5, with 48 reviews. Most positive reviews focused on comfort and price, while unfavorable reviews claimed the mattress was too firm.

With 91 reviews, Casper only received an average of 3.4 stars. While favorable reviews cited comfort levels and customer service, negative reviews revealed that some customers found it uncomfortable to sleep on.

Amazon

Known for their straightforward, even blunt reviews, Amazon customers rated Tuft and Needle 4.2 out of 5 stars, with a total of over 6,500 reviews. Some customers appreciated the customer service, while several others rated the mattress highly only after adding the company’s 2-inch tall foam mattress topper. Overall, T&N received 85 percent positive reviews expression customer satisfaction.

Amazon customers gave the Casper Sleep foam mattress 4.0 out of 5 stars with a total of 760 total reviews. Casper rated about 69 percent positive customer feedback. Many found that the product over-promised and under-delivered, particularly for the price point. Others complained that the mattress wasn’t supportive enough for those with back pain. Those who rated it highly claimed it provided the perfect balance of softness and support for them.

Tuft and Needle vs Casper: How we reviewed

​To create our side-by-side comparison of the Tuft and Needle and Casper Sleep foam mattress, we collated date from consumer advocate sites, customer reviews, and industry experts. From this data, we developed a systemic analysis to provide the most significant differences between the two products. We discounted customer reviews on the manufacturers’ websites because they’re so often gained with incentives such as free products or discounts.

Pros and Cons: How Do Tuft and Needle vs Casper Compare?

​Both companies provide similar products that vary widely in price and comfort while remaining similar in performance and durability. So, the breakdown of each mattress’s high and low points may provide perspective.

Tuft and Needle

Tuft & Needle Queen Mattress, Bed in a Box

​The pros and cons of the Tuft and Needle:

Pros

  • ​Offers both comfort and support for the average-sized sleeper
  • ​Extremely good price
  • ​Excellent reputation for customer service
  • ​Higher customer ratings

Cons

  • ​Might be too firm for average or large back sleepers
  • ​Customers say it’s not as cool to sleep on as claimed
  • ​Not optimal for sitting up in bed
  • ​Mediocre support around the edge

Casper Sleep

Sale
Casper Sleep Foam Mattress, Queen 10"
  • 4-layer memory foam construction for support, breathability, and bounce
  • Open-cell hypoallergenic latex designed to keep you cool all night
  • Softer foam under shoulder region and firm, supportive foam in core and hip area

​The pros and cons of the Casper Sleep:

Pros

  • ​Memory foam layer offers conformance to body shape
  • ​Provides a cool sleep as advertised
  • ​Financing offered through the Casper website

Cons

  • ​Memory foam layer can collapse over time
  • ​Can take a while to grow accustomed to the bed
  • ​Might be overhyped by aggressive marketing

Tuft and Needle vs Casper: Which Bed to Choose?

Sleep may be the most vulnerable part of anyone’s day, and it’s also the most intimate. Mattress comfort relies solely on subjective preferences. This makes choosing a mattress a very personal endeavor. Customers who like a softer mattress may prefer the Casper, especially if they like the “hug” of memory foam. Those who prefer a firmer model may want to choose the T&N.

Sleepers who frequently wake with sore shoulders and hips from pressing on their mattress will certainly appreciate the Casper model. Customers also often prefer it for the “cool sleep.” So, consider this model if night sweats, hot flashes, or overheating wake you through the night.

However, if you’re on a tight budget, Tuft and Needle’s prices guarantee good quality for a smaller cost. Whichever mattress you choose, you’ll find that both offer a 100-night trial period with no obligation.

If you’ve purchased a compressed foam mattress-in-a-box before, tell us about your experience in the comments. Did they compare to a traditional mattress? Which one gave you the best night’s sleep?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here