Wondering If the My Pillow Mattress Topper Is Right for You?

my pillow mattress topper

A good mattress topper is much cheaper than a luxury mattress, and it can achieve the same results without the hassle of replacing your bed. In addition to comfort, it can also help with those two common problems that come from sub-par sleeping conditions. I’m talking about overheating and pain. Poor sleeping posture and weight distribution can cause aches and misalignment. That makes the My Pillow mattress topper and similar products a worthy investment.

When you feel the pressure relief and airy, cradling contour, you’ll sleep deeper and wake up feeling better. And, best of all, you can move your topper from one bed to another.

A Closer Look at the My Pillow Mattress Topper

The three-inch foam My Pillow mattress topper provides extra comfort if you’re not happy with the firmness of your bed. With its different layers of foam, it molds to your body to keep you in a neutral position.

Build Quality

a women using a pillow mattress

Image from Pixabay

There are three layers to the My Pillow mattress topper. The first layer is a solid piece of My Pillow patented foam. This layer provides most of the support and strength. The second layer consists of transitional foam which distributes your body weight evenly to relieve pressure points and give better comfort. Its final layer is a Phase Change Material cover which helps keep you fresh through the night by dispersing heat and moisture.

The cover has a zipper for easy removal. It’s washable and dryable, and easy to put back. Four corner straps keep the My Pillow mattress topper firmly in place. The bottom has a non-skid surface for extra steadiness. That, combined with the low motion transfer, makes it a good option for couples and restless sleepers.

Due to its simple structure without loose or moving parts, there’s not much that can go wrong. It can handle normal use without any risk of damage. It’ll last you a long time, especially if you rotate it when you change the sheets. As for firmness, the mattress is about a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. That means it gives plenty of support while remaining comfortable for most people.

Sleeping on it

Thanks to the thickness, it will yield more or less the same results regardless of the mattress underneath. You’re most likely to enjoy the My Pillow mattress topper if you find your mattress too soft. It’s very supportive, and you don’t sink into it like you would on a memory foam mattress. You stay on top, but it’s still soft enough to provide comfort. It’ll cradle your body and produce an almost floating feeling. For someone like me who sometimes has shoulder pain, a mattress topper like this one is a relief. However, it’s not ideal for those who prefer a really soft bed.

When it comes to temperature, it’s about average for a foam mattress topper. The cover provides decent airflow, but it’s best to use a fitted sheet with the My Pillow mattress topper. It’s easy to fit a sheet with deep pockets onto it, and it won’t slide around and wrinkle up.

Edge support is always a slight issue with foam mattress toppers, and the My Pillow mattress topper is no different. So if you like sitting on the edge of the bed, you may have to adjust to the sinking feeling. Then again, three extra inches can make up for this.

Buyers like the firm feel, coolness, and pressure point relief. However, some find it too firm.


While you can find a My Pillow mattress topper in certain physical stores, they’re often cheaper and easier to find online.

The My Pillow mattress topper comes with a 10-year warranty. And there’s a 60-day money back guarantee if you’re unhappy with it.

How the My Pillow Mattress Topper Compares to Competition

To give you a better idea of the quality of the My Pillow mattress topper, we’ll now compare it against a few key competitors. We’ve chosen Sleep Innovations, Lucid, and SleepJoy mattress toppers for this comparison.

How we reviewed

brown pillow in the bed

Image from Pixabay

These reviews resulted from research on user experiences and reviews from across the web. Amazon customer reviews are the primary source.

Sleep Innovations 4-inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper

Sleep Innovations Dual Layer 4 Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper, King...
  • Dual Layer King Size Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper: This luxurious 2 layer mattress topper features a 2 inch soft...
  • Bedtime Made Better: This gel foam mattress topper offers plush support for all sleep positions; The 2 inch pillow top...
  • Instantly Improve Any Mattress: Relieve pressure points, enjoy deeper sleep, and wake up feeling refreshed with our line...

Comfort that knows you, that’s how they market it. This mattress topper is thicker and has a different makeup than the My Pillow mattress topper, but they’re comparable in general.

Build Quality

It’s a similar layered approach, but with two inches of cooling gel memory foam and two inches of fiber-filling. A soft, quilted cover enhances the soft, airy design. This cover is also washable and dryable.

On the firmness scale, this is a five or six out of ten. It offers a gentle, cradling medium feel. The gel memory foam disperses heat to prevent hot, sweaty sleep. It also helps the mattress topper conform to your body.

The overall build is solid with quality materials. One downside to the build of this mattress topper is that it may develop body impressions over time. If this happens, it won’t provide the support you need for a neutral spine position.

​Sleeping on it

The Sleep Innovations topper is the kind that has a puffy cloud feel. You’ll sink into it more than the My Pillow mattress topper. Since it’s thick, it cradles you well. That also means that you won’t be able to move as freely as you would on a firmer topper. It’s a good option if you want plush comfort, but it may not be the right choice if you have back problems.

mattress pillow in the bedroom with desing of it

Image from Pixabay

That’s not to say it’s not supportive. And if you have a firm bed, it’s an excellent complement. The gel foam provides a cooler feel than typical memory foam and makes it more adaptable. If you’re a hot sleeper, you’ll appreciate it.

Buyers like the cushy feel and the cool temperature. The main complaint is that it doesn’t maintain its structure that well.


It’s close in price to the My Pillow mattress topper. There is a 10-year limited warranty and the company has a 60-day return policy.

​Lucid 4-inch Bamboo Charcoal Memory Foam Mattress Topper

LUCID has a different take on the foam mattress topper concept. It’s simpler, but it features special infused materials. If you like the feel of memory foam, this topper is worth considering.

Build Quality

This mattress topper is a single slab of memory foam. It’s airy and soft with a bamboo charcoal infusion. The charcoal helps regulate temperature and moisture. It also reduces smells and gives a cleaner sleeping experience.

The ventilated design helps keep you cool at night. In addition to better airflow, it also creates a softer feel than the average memory foam mattress topper. This, in turn, improves pressure relief. The foam is hypoallergenic and supports your spine.

Sleeping on it

Being a foam slab, it does sleep a bit hot compared to fluffier designs. It’s not too different from the My Pillow mattress topper, but the lack of a dedicated layer for dispersing heat and moisture makes a difference. The bamboo charcoal does help with moisture. However, you’ll want to use breathable sheets for best results.

There’s nothing to complain about when it comes to support. It can help relieve pain in your back, hips, and shoulders. It cradles you without making you feel like you’re sleeping inside it. It’s best for back sleepers. If you sleep on your side, it’ll still be comfortable and supportive, but you’ll sink more. It’s not as firm as the My Pillow mattress topper. You may find it somewhat awkward to move around on it. And if you’re close to the edge, you may feel like you’re about to fall off. It’s normal for this type of mattress.

Buyers like its puffy feel and pressure relief. Complaints revolve around temperature and sometimes imprecise dimensions.


The LUCID mattress topper costs about the same as the My Pillow mattress topper. You get a 3-year Warranty and 30 days to return it if you’re not satisfied.

​Sleepjoy 3-inch Visco2 Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper

SleepJoy 3" ViscO2 Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Queen,...
  • INSTANT MATTRESS ENHANCEMENT: Easily upgrade your mattress with a luxurious layer of high-quality memory foam. When you...
  • BREATHABLE DESIGN: Cooler sleep means deeper sleep, so we designed this mattress topper for maximum breathability. Our...
  • PREMIUM MEMORY FOAM: Our ViscO2 memory foam offers superior durability, holding its shape over time for years of...

It’s always good to compare against a budget option. The SleepJoy mattress topper fits that role well. It’s similar enough, but at a lower price point.

Build Quality

An open cell memory foam design gives it good airflow throughout the mattress. Extra ventilation ensures that you can stay cool and sleep well. The ViscO2 memory foam is more durable than regular memory foam, so it’s better at staying supportive over time. They make it in part from castor beans, which makes it easier on the environment than ordinary memory foam.

​Sleeping on it

Unlike the typical foam topper, this one’s ready for use straight out of the box and doesn’t have that sharp new mattress smell. It’s much softer than the My Pillow mattress topper. This topper is the kind that you sink into. It’s good for side sleepers and heavy-set individuals. But it may not be so good for back sleepers who are prone to lower back pain. However, if you want to add some cushioning to a firm mattress, this is a good option.

When it comes to temperature control, it’s about average. It can keep most people cool, but if you like it really cool, it may not be enough. It does breathe well and reduce moisture.

When you get out of bed, the foam regains its original shape fast. So it should last longer than many affordable foam toppers. Especially if you rotate the topper often.

Buyers like the cushy feel and how it adapts to side sleepers. What they don’t like is that it may cause discoloration, and the dimensions may be imprecise.

Pros and Cons

With all that out of the way, it’s time to round this up. Here are the strengths and drawbacks of the My Pillow mattress topper.


  • Healthy support
  • Easy maintenance
  • Stays in place
  • Good breathability

If you want that medium-firm feel and to make sure that your spine stays neutral, a My Pillow mattress topper is an excellent choice. It’s thick enough to give any bed the luxury feel you desire.


  • Not the coolest option
  • Some find it too firm

Foam mattresses and toppers aren’t that cool in general, so it’s nothing out of the ordinary. The alternatives here are all comparable in that regard. But if you want a softer feel, the Lucid or SleepJoy may suit you better than the My Pillow mattress topper.

Sleep Innovations Dual Layer 4 Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper, King...

Image from Amazon

Our Verdict

In fewer words, the My Pillow mattress topper offers a good balance of support and comfort. It’s airy and has the implements to wick away moisture. It can keep you aligned for a good night’s sleep without aches and overheating. The price is about average, but the warranty is generous. So, if you want that added luxury feel, a My Pillow mattress topper is an excellent choice.

Last update on 2023-06-06 at 13:48 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API